![]() ![]() It simply does not have the agency or capability to do anything but provide derivative responses in the face of human-initiated prompts.įor these reasons and so many more, ChatGPT does not represent any meaningful replacement for writers, educators or human professionals in general. Most fundamentally, ChatGPT cannot actually ask questions of its own at all. Indeed, ChatGPT cannot engage a learner in a two-way dialogue - considering their state of mind and developmental needs - in order to provide personalized feedback and help them understand a new concept. Notably, ChatGPT cannot facilitate higher-order conceptual learning. In this context, learning denotes higher-order cognitive development beyond simple memorization of facts or information it requires the development of conceptual understanding alongside an ability to analyze and evaluate the meaning and significance of the topic at hand. Here again, it is important to qualify what we mean by learning. Similarly, the science of human learning has shown us that students learn not only through their abilities of reasoning, interpretation and creative expression - which ChatGPT lacks - but also with the help of teachers who engage them in a two-way dialogue accompanied by feedback that is adjusted to their understanding and overall needs. ![]() Today, audio recording technology is an important tool for journalists but one wielded in service to its human users. What this suggestion failed to recognize is that journalists don’t simply record what someone says they interpret it and, most importantly, ask questions to understand or even challenge what they are hearing. When audio recording technology became commonplace in newsgathering during the 20th century, some suggested that it would replace many journalists who would otherwise attend news conferences and other newsworthy events. This is the first and most fundamental reason that ChatGPT cannot ever truly replace professional writers - whether they be journalists, novelists or academics. While ChatGPT can respond to creative inquiries and even some metaphorical prompts with seemingly meaningful replies, it is important to remember that it is simply reconstituting existing language without any thought, free creation or metaphorical meaning of its own. Telling someone that you are “trying to keep your head above water” at work is nonsensical when interpreted literally, yet extremely meaningful to a human mind that can understand the shared conceptual relationships between overwhelming workload and the struggle to not drown. While poetry and literary metaphor are one part of this, everyday metaphor is a much larger phenomenon that allows us to communicate beyond the literal. Second, this phrase also reminds us that a large amount of natural human language is symbolic and metaphorical. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |